UPDATE: New York Mag's Pop Critic Jody Rosen Responds with Shelfie to Tongue-Tied Ted Gioa's Daily Beast Column

By Logan K. Young on Mar 21, 2014 06:03 PM EDT

UPDATE: Like ex-SPIN scribe Charles Aaron tweeted at the start of the fracas, the best way to get another critic to recognize your work is to simply slag them off. And so, Jody Rosen of New York magazine's Vulture blog did just that...with a shelfie

Not to be outdone, Pitchfork's Mike Powell delivered the next jab, followed by ex-Village Voice music editor Maura Johnston via her Tumblr. 

Other retorts:

Evan Sawdey for Popmatters

Tom Hawking for Flavorwire

James Inverne for Classicalite

A very interesting piece comes to us from Ted Gioia at The Daily Beast about music criticism, or rather its death, or rather its inability or unwillingness to use technical language or display, you know, any kind of actual knowledge. It's especially interesting because it seems to take the viewpoint of mainstream, pop music criticism, referencing outlets like Billboard and even American Idol (I know, that last isn't exactly a bastion of intelligent criticism but apparently Harry Connick, Jr. was sniggered at for using the word "pentatonic"). Sigh.

Classical music, which is actually still reviewed in more technical terms, at least in its specialist journals (I write having been the editor of perhaps the most prominent,Gramophone), also suffers from this somewhat. But to nothing like the same extent as pop. On the other hand, I'd argue that pop music is shorter-form and therefore often much less complex than its classical cousin. However, classical music critics have been lamenting the slow diminution of the critical vocabulary for years. Opera magazine about three or four years ago ran an excellent piece about just that.

But the root of the problem is not the writers, as Slate infers. There are always great writers. But the editors sometimes, themselves, suffer from a lack of knowledge and don't know what they should be looking for. And the publishers don't want to pay for the best of the best, at least not in music writing. So, while there are still fabulous writers around, their incentives to keep writing are hardly irresistible.

But it's emphatically not that readers don't have the patience or appetite for linguistically adept reviews. Because other genres have, if anything, developed on that front--take a look at some of the film criticism around, or the visual arts. There at least a few mainstream critics are not afraid to reach for esoteric comparisons or even the odd technical phrase.

Has there ever been such a serious discussion happening around graphic novels, or what we used to call comic books? What are those forms doing right that music is getting wrong?

© 2016 The Classical Art, All rights reserved. Do not reproduce without permission.

TagsThe Daily Beast, Ted Gioia, Billboard, American Idol, Harry Connick Jr., Gramophone, Slate, Charles Aaron

Real Time Analytics